What does PID mean in an espresso machine?

PID stands for proportional, integral and derivative: three components of an electronic temperature control. With a sensor, the control follows the temperature and calculates how much heating is needed to stay close to the set value. A PID can work together with a boiler or thermoblock and helps limit temperature fluctuations. Whether you can set the temperature yourself depends on your machine.

A thermostat switches the heating on and off. A PID does that on many machines as well. Why then can one control work more accurately than the other?

The difference lies in the information the control reacts to. A simple thermostat uses fixed switching limits. A PID also takes into account how the temperature develops. Because of this, it can reduce the heating earlier if the system gets warmer quickly.

As Geert-Jan the Baristaman, I am happy to help you understand what such properties mean during coffee making. We start with the control itself and then look at your espresso, milk drinks and maintenance.

Close-up van een temperatuurdisplay met de waarde 93 op een espressomachine.

Three ways to look at temperature

A PID compares the measured temperature with the set temperature. In doing so, it uses both the current difference and the rate at which it is changing.

How do proportional, integral, and derivative work?

A temperature sensor measures how warm the system is at the location where the sensor is installed. The controller compares this measurement with the desired temperature and then activates the heating element.

Proportionalrelates to the difference at this moment. If the measured temperature is much lower than the target, that requires more heating than when the difference is small.

Integraltakes deviations that accumulate over time into account. If the temperature consistently stays slightly below the desired value, this component can help eliminate that persistent deviation.

Differentiallooks at how quickly the measured temperature is changing. When it rises quickly, this component can help reduce the heating earlier.

Together, these components determine the fine-tuning. As a home barista, you do not need to know the underlying calculations. The manufacturer tunes the controller to the machine. Furthermore, setting the desired brewing temperature is something different from changing the technical P-, I-, and D-settings; you normally leave those as they are.

Schematisch temperatuurverloop: een eenvoudige thermostaat schakelt op grenzen, een PID gebruikt ook het verloop. Geen meetresultaten.

Heat remains even after switching off

A hot heating element does not cool down immediately once the power stops. That residual heat helps explain why the temperature can overshoot.

What is the difference between a PID and a thermostat?

Imagine a simple thermostat that switches the heater on at 92 Β°C and off at 94 Β°C. These are merely example values, not settings for your machine.

As soon as the upper limit is reached, the heater stops. The hot element and the surrounding material continue to release heat. This can cause the temperature to rise further. After switching back on, it may take a similar amount of time before the heater compensates for a drop.

A PID also uses the temperature trend. If the temperature is rapidly approaching the setpoint, the controller can reduce the heating before that setpoint is reached.

This is often done with short on-off pulses: for part of the time, the element is on. This reduces the average amount of heat added. But the pulses are merely the implementation. The essential difference is the calculation that determines how much heating is required.

With both control systems, the temperature can fluctuate. A well-tuned PID can reduce those fluctuations; it does not keep the temperature perfectly still.

Vereenvoudigde werking van thermoblock, single boiler, warmtewisselaar en dual boiler.

Heating and control go together

A thermoblock is a component that heats water. A thermostat or PID determines how that heating is controlled.

How does PID differ from a thermoblock, boiler, or heat exchanger?

In a thermoblock, water flows through channels in heated metal. A thermocoiluses a water pipe in a heated structure. These systems can be ready for use quickly; their performance depends on the design and control.

A single boilerhas one boiler for coffee and steam. Different temperatures are required for espresso and frothing milk. You therefore switch between both functions and must take waiting time into account.

In a heat exchanger, often called HX, the brewing water flows through a separate circuit in a hot steam boiler. Such machines can usually brew coffee and steam at the same time. The brewing temperature also depends on flow rate, standstill, and construction.

A dual boilerhas separate boilers for coffee and steam. This setup allows for separate control and usually supports brewing and steaming at the same time.

PID can be applied to various designs. In an HX, it often controls the steam boiler, which indirectly influences the brewing temperature. A pressure switchcontrols that boiler via steam pressure. Therefore, check what the control in the specific model actually measures and controls.

Een hand houdt een melkkan vast terwijl melk wordt opgeschuimd met de stoompijp.

What coffee do you make every day?

When choosing a machine, I first look at your drinks. Espresso, in particular, requires different usage characteristics than making several cappuccinos in a row.

What does PID mean if you also want to froth milk?

If someone asks during a workshop which machine they should choose, I first ask whether they want to make milk-based coffees with it. For cappuccino, flat white and caffè latte, the machine must also be able to heat and froth milk comfortably.

A machine with a suitable steam boiler is then worth considering. Sufficient steam capacity helps to froth milk quickly, especially when making several drinks. When comparing specific models, consider the boiler capacity, power and steam wand.

A single boiler usually requires switching between brewing coffee and steaming. A heat exchanger or dual boiler can make this routine easier, as coffee and steam are available at the same time.

Thermoblock machines can also froth milk. How quickly and powerfully they do so varies depending on the model.

A PID for coffee heating does not make the machine more powerful at steaming on its own. Some machines also electronically control the steam boiler. Therefore, look at the temperature control for espresso and milk frothing performance separately.

Espressomachine met vastgezette filterdrager, een kopje op het rooster en een kopje bovenop.

From temperature display to taste

The temperature affects what dissolves in the water from the ground coffee. However, the number on your display does not tell you everything about the conditions under which your espresso is brewed.

What do you notice about PID and temperature in your espresso?

During brewing, water extracts substances from the ground coffee. This process is called extraction. The temperature affects this process and can therefore also change the taste.

A more consistent temperature helps to brew espressos under comparable conditions. However, a sour espresso does not prove that your machine is set too low. The grind, amount of ground coffee, espresso yield, and characteristics of the beans also play a role.

The temperature display also requires context. For example, the sensor may measure the boiler, while the manufacturer displays an adjusted value that approximates the brewing temperature. What exactly you are reading varies by machine.

In addition, other components need to absorb heat. The group head, in which you lock the portafilter, and the portafilter itself may still be warming up while the heating system is already ready.

Therefore, follow the preparation instructions in the manual. Keep your warm-up routine and method consistent when comparing espressos. This will make it clearer whether a difference in taste is related to a setting or to a different start to your preparation.

Espresso stroomt uit een dubbele uitloop in een klein wit kopje op een koffieweegschaal.

Make changes recognizable

A change in temperature is easier to assess when your preparation is already repeatable. That is why I start with the quantities, grind size, and brew time.

Learn the three golden rules of espresso

When does it make sense to adjust the PID temperature?

My advice is to first get the basics of espresso extraction under control. Weigh the ground coffee in your filter basket, measure how much espresso ends up in your cup, and keep track of the brew time. That is the time it takes to make the espresso; always use the same method of measurement when making comparisons.

In The 3 Golden Rules of Espresso, I explain how you can get more control over your preparation with fixed measurement points.

A coffee scale with timer from Barista Essentialshelps you keep track of quantities and time.

Affiliate: via this link you will be redirected to Barista Essentials. They handle the order, shipping, returns, and the right of withdrawal. Geert-Jan de Baristamanreceives a commission without you paying any extra for it.

When your espresso comes out consistently from the machine, you can explore the brewing temperature as an additional setting. Change one setting at a time and let the machine stabilize according to the manual. Keep the other parts of your recipe the same and taste the difference. This is how you discover what a temperature change does to your coffee.

Een filterdrager wordt met een borstel schoongemaakt; het losse filterbakje ligt bij de gootsteen.

A regulation does not keep your machine clean

Coffee oils, milk residue and limescale each require appropriate maintenance. A temperature setting cannot resolve that kind of buildup.

Why do cleaning and descaling remain important for a PID machine?

If your espresso tastes less pleasant, also look at the parts that come into contact with coffee. Residual coffee grounds and oils in the filter basket, portafilter, and brewing group can affect the taste. Milk residues around the steam wand require their own cleaning routine.

Descaling has a different purpose: removing limescale that can build up from the water used. That buildup can affect the operation of the machine. PID does not prevent limescale formation and does not replace maintenance.

Therefore, use the right treatment for the right problem. A coffee oil remover is not a descaler. How often descaling is needed depends on several factors, including your water and the instructions for the model.

In Cleaning and maintenanceI will help you understand these differences and establish a maintenance routine.

For limescale, also consult the descaling information for different espresso machinesand the manual for your model. Some machines require descaling by a specialist. Therefore, do not make a general descaling routine a regular habit for every machine.

Learn to maintain your espresso machine

Frequently asked questions about PID in espresso machines

Does a PID only give short heating bursts?

Many control systems operate the element using short on-off pulses. The most important thing is how the PID calculates how much heating is needed. A control system that uses pulses is therefore not automatically a PID.

Can a thermoblock have a PID?

Here's how to download your digital products:

Does the temperature always remain exactly the same with PID?

No. A well-tuned PID helps limit fluctuations. The sensor, tuning, water flow, and construction of the machine also determine how stable the temperature actually is.

Can you change the brewing temperature on every PID machine?

That varies by model. Some machines offer adjustable temperatures, while others maintain a fixed temperature electronically. In the case of a heat exchanger, a setting may also refer to the steam boiler. Check the manual for the meaning.

Do you also need to descale a machine with PID?

No, our products are free from allergens and therefore gluten-free. We only use natural ingredients and don't add any unnecessary additives.

I have another question.

Contact Geert-Jan the Barista

How do you use PID to better understand your coffee?

A PID helps fine-tune the heating based on temperature readings and their trends. The benefits you notice from this depend on the construction of your machine and your preparation.

When choosing a machine, you should therefore look at two things: can the heating system prepare your desired espresso and milk drinks, and how is the temperature controlled? For your existing machine, the benefits start with proper preparation, maintenance, and a recipe you can replicate.

After that, you can use temperature to further explore your taste. With De Barista Shop, I help you make better coffee by making such steps understandable and applicable at your own kitchen counter.

Do you want to first learn which quantities and measurement points help you compare espresso? Build a solid foundation before you start changing additional settings.

Discover The 3 Golden Rules of Espresso
Online barista module drie gouden regels voor goede espresso zetten

Learn why your espresso tastes different

With The 3 Golden Rules of Espresso, you will learn to pay attention to the amount of ground coffee, the espresso yield, and the extraction time. The video and PDF will help you build a consistent foundation, so you can better assess changes in your preparation.

View the online espresso module

Discover more related articles

View all
1 3
View all
Espressomachine met temperatuurdisplay en koffiemolen op een houten keukenblad.

β˜• What is a PID in an espresso machine, and what does it do?

When you compare espresso machines, you will quickly come across the word PID. Sometimes it is listed next to a temperature display, sometimes in a list of features. Then the practical question remains: what does that control system do while you are making coffee?

During my workshops, I start with what you want to drink at home. Especially espresso, or regularly cappuccino and flat white? Based on that daily routine, you can better judge which heating and temperature control suit you.

I will take you through the operation of PID, the difference with a simple thermostat, and the significance of boilers and thermoblocks. I will also explain when adjusting the temperature becomes a meaningful next step.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.